A Rare Disease True Crime Story
Sometimes truth is stranger than fiction, and rare disease is a mystery for most people, including those who have it. At a mystery writers conference I attended in Boston, one of the presenters was a Medical Examiner, who served as the consultant for the TV show, Crossing Jordan. She shared her unusual cases with the audience, who were looking for realism and inspiration for their writing.
My ears perked up as she spoke about a terrible story that occurred in 1989 when a woman named Patricia Stallings brought her baby into the ER after the child was vomiting and having difficulty breathing. As the doctors examined the baby, they found high levels of ethylene glycol in the child’s blood, which they suspected was due to antifreeze poisoning. As a result, they removed the child from the mother’s care. Four days after the mother visited her child in foster care, the child became very ill again, and the mother was arrested. The child died shortly after, and the mother was convicted for her son’s murder.
While serving a life sentence in prison, she gave birth to another child. The child was placed in foster care, but soon the second child also started having symptoms. The medical examiner was called in to study the baby’s bottle, to find proof it had been tampered with poison. After further analysis of the blood with a biochemistry professor, the examiner realized what was misidentified as ethylene glycol was actually propionic acid. The medical examiner remembered a lecture she had in medical school about a genetic disease that caused the body to produce propionic acid, and, after consultation with specialists, the baby was diagnosed with methylmalonic acidemia (MMA).
The mother served two years in prison before being released in 1991, following proof that the lab testing of the blood samples of the first child had mistakenly identified propionic acid as ethylene glycol, and that he had MMA.
This story is a cautionary reminder of the many kinds of challenges that people living with rare diseases have faced. Fortunately, with prenatal screening tests available in most states, rare diseases, such as methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) and propionic acidemia (PA), are being diagnosed sooner. With better diagnostics and research into these diseases, we can only hope that, in the future, stories like the one of Patricia Stallings will serve as historical or fictional inspiration.
Latest from Know Rare
Discover the latest treatments for IgA Nephropathy (IgAN), a rare kidney disease. Learn how current medications and emerging therapies work to slow progression, reduce proteinuria, and protect kidney function.
Discover how patient education empowers individuals with rare diseases to better understand their diagnosis, make informed decisions, and actively participate in their treatment plans. Learn why clear, compassionate communication is key to improving outcomes in rare disease care.
A heartfelt mother’s account on five years of navigating pediatric specialist waiting rooms with her medically complex child.
A powerful personal journey through Koolen-de Vries syndrome, ADHD, and neurodivergent parenting. Discover how one mother turned diagnosis into empowerment, embracing difference, healing guilt, and raising resilient, remarkable children in a world that doesn’t always understand.
Toni Roberts lives with Epidermolysis Bullosa, a rare genetic disorder that causes the skin to be extremely fragile and prone to blistering and tearing. Toni’s condition profoundly impacted her older sister, Cady Ward. Witnessing Toni’s daily struggles and challenges, Cady was inspired to become an advocate for rare disease and take on an extraordinary challenge—run an ultra-marathon.
Dr. David Fajgenbaum was in his third year of medical school when a rare and mysterious illness derailed his plans. Crushing fatigue, abdominal pain, and multiple swollen lymph nodes progressed rapidly, and he found himself in the ICU with multiple system organ failure. Recovering from the brink of death, he was diagnosed with Castleman disease (CD), a rare condition that at the time was thought to be a lymph node disease with similarities to cancer.
Learn about Dr. Rohit Aggarwal’s efforts in creating more centers of excellence for myositis, as well as educating, empowering, and connecting patients to clinical trials.
Recognizing the need for an effective way to treat becker muscular dystrophy, researchers have been studying the cause of muscle loss, and ways to stop it from happening.
After his diagnosis of limb-girdle muscular dystrophy type 2B at age 21, Chris initially opted for a safe career path, choosing jobs with steady income, benefits, and predictability. However, this decision made him feel like something was missing. Find out how Chris was finally able to follow his heart, finding purpose and contentment in becoming a writer.
Learn more about CureGRIN, founded in 2018 by parents of children diagnosed with GRIN Disorder to help find cures and therapies for people around the world suffering from these conditions.
Learn about the incredible story of Edward Gent, a Sports Nutritionist diagnosed with MMN, who decided to create an app to help others worldwide with their disease and symptom management.
Find out about 7 research areas identified as priorities in Sickle Cell Research and about a sickle cell disease drug, which was originally approved for treatment, that has been taken off the market.
It’s no secret that it is difficult to get to a pain medicine specialist. There are just so many people in pain who cannot find relief, and are looking for help. Learn about Bliss Health, which provides access to pain management services through virtual consultations, through a dedicated team of medical professionals who specialize in the diagnosis, treatment, and ongoing management of various types of chronic and acute pain conditions.
There are over 50 million people in the United States that live with chronic pain. However, researchers studying pain have learned something important: perception of pain is personal, and may have more to do with other factors than just the physical cause of the pain.
If you are coming across high copays and struggling to afford your treatment plan, here are a few options that may help you reduce the costs of your medications.
At age 15, Becca Salky became her own medical detective, playing a key role in uncovering her diagnosis. Now, as a Clinical Research Coordinator at Massachusetts General Hospital, she focuses on spreading awareness about MOG, finding better diagnostic tools, leading clinical trials, and fighting gender disparity.
On the “Rare Insights” podcast we bridge the gap between those living with rare diseases and the biopharmaceutical industry.
Why Men’s Health Week (June 10-16) matters for the Rare Community, and how you can take part.
June is Pride Month, and at Know Rare, we are committed to celebrating the rich diversity within the rare disease community.
Journalist Lindsay Guentzel describes navigating a diagnostic odyssey and how she manages day-to-day life with myositis in an impactful webinar.
When you live with a rare disease, the joyful experiences risks can bring are all the more valuable.
This summer, NMOSD and MOGAD patients, caregivers, clinicians, nurses, researchers, and advocates are invited to join The Sumaira Foundation at Emory for TSF's Atlanta Patient Day.
Know Rare writer Gina DeMillo Wagner’s new memoir, Forces of Nature explores powerful themes related to caregiving and rare disease.
Journalist Lindsay Guentzel offers an inside look at life with the rare muscular condition.
This May, Know Rare is shining a light on myositis, a group of rare autoimmune muscle diseases that can have profound effects on daily life. This is an important time for the myositis community and the rare disease community at large: a time to share stories from those living with the condition, share more information about the current state and future of the disease, and advocate for better treatments that will ultimately enhance the quality of life for those impacted by it. Whether you're a patient, caregiver, or advocate, join us in raising awareness and supporting those affected by myositis.
Author Chris Anselmo explains why being mindful of your pace can have major benefits for your health and well-being, and offers some tips to help.
